Opinions(?) What's the "Cleanest" sounding guitar?

  • Thread starter freshchops
  • Start date
  • This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links like Ebay, Amazon, and others.

freshchops

Tele-Meister
Joined
Jan 18, 2010
Posts
339
Location
Louisiana-USA
Granted, this niche of the web may be biased, but I'like to hear what everyone's experiences are with the cleanest guitars and why. "Clean" could be vague and different to everyone's ears, but I'm trying to consolidate guitars and ultimately in search for the cleanest of clean tone. So much consideration is given to the amps in this regard and rightfully so. But what would you consider the cleanest guitar?

By clean's, I'm referring to: bright, articulate, thick, full, warm, chimey, etc.
Charateristics to avoid: thin, brittle, harsh, muddy, too hot, too dull, etc.

With so many components and factors from pick-ups, body/neck woods, size, weights, hardware, solid /hollows, wiring/pots... I know they each play a factor. I'm just curious, from others experience, what total setup made for the cleanest tones overall.

Think of it in comparison to "Cleanest Amp" talk... they all follow similar circuitry, speaker, tubes, etc... but some are just "Clean" by the truest definition. I'd claim that a Twin Reverb is the cleanest, but others may say a Roland Jazz Chorus 120, etc, etc... What some call clean, also isn't without varying degrees of subtle break-up and sparkle, so.

I have a few Tele's and a couple Strats. The tele's are very sparkly and clean (of course) and would be my go-to for clean, but I'm curious - does it get better? A deluxe tele with wide range humbuckers is more thick and round, though it's also muddy in the lows. Strats, clean of course, but also tend to get growly and twangy and kinda squawky in the highs. I love all of these tones and guitars, but looking for the cleanest of cleans!

For example, I had a Rickenbacker 650D Dakota. It had such a "wooden" tone. It felt almost like strumming on a marimba. It was very thick and round sounding with little natural breakup from pickup output. It was the thickest cleans I can imagine but also the dullest guitar I've owned for lack of sparkle.
Jazzmaster's too - had one, loved it but had to sell it. It might be the most articulate cleans I've ever played. But, does it get better? Gretsch's, Gibson hollow-body's, Rickenbackers, other Fender's (like less common offset models), etc...???
 

MilwMark

Doctor of Teleocity
Joined
Apr 29, 2013
Posts
13,804
Location
near Arnold's
I don't mean to be a wet blanket, but you are way over-thinking this.

All depends on how you set the amp and where/how you attack the strings, with what pick (or no pick). Once you get outside some very basic parameters (hot ceramic humbuckers break up sooner, whatever) pickups that stay clean longer for me might dirty up sooner for you.
 

Nick Fanis

Poster Extraordinaire
Ad Free Member
Joined
Mar 3, 2003
Posts
7,803
Location
Athens-GREECE
any guitar with low output pups has the potential to sound great clean through a great AMP.The amp of course is still WAY more important than the guitar.
I play clean 90% of the time,have tried almost every type of guitar ever built and nothing sounds as good clean as the middle position on a good telecaster with vintage style pups through a tweed deluxe set at "2".

A nice Gretsch through a bf Fender amp sounds killer clean too .
 
Last edited:

jman72

Friend of Leo's
Joined
Aug 31, 2013
Posts
2,262
Location
Central Florida
Lots of guitars have great clean tone. I get my favorite cleans from my strat and my sg. Both sound amazingly clean Through my sftr.
 

Steve 78

Friend of Leo's
Joined
Oct 27, 2015
Posts
2,563
Age
47
Location
Melbourne, Austraila
Of the main guitar types, Teles sound cleanest to me. Humbucking guitars are muddier. Strats have that floating almost reverb-y sound. I've never played a Gretch, Dano or about a million other guitar types though so I couldn't comment there.
 

Kojer

Tele-Meister
Joined
Sep 11, 2015
Posts
375
Location
Manila, PH
Most guitars can be made to sound clean, just roll of the volume, but my fender strat sounds wonderful clean.
 

Flyinlow

Tele-Meister
Joined
Feb 9, 2017
Posts
233
Location
NE Indiana
Stratocasters. Whether like Knopfler, Steve Miller, or even Hendrix, Stratocasters are wonderfully clean if you set everything that way. Sounds like bells.
 

Dismalhead

Doctor of Teleocity
Joined
Feb 16, 2014
Posts
12,115
Age
62
Location
Antelope, California
I've got Teles and Strats. I would argue that the Tele is the cleanest over the Strat. If I were to try to dial up an electric so that it sounds like an acoustic guitar, I'd use my Tele in the mid position with both pickups. In my band I've even swapped a few of the songs I used to play with my acoustic to my Tele. The quack of a Strat is coloring the sound with a slight curly que. That's what makes it great, but IMO it's not natural sounding. It's like adding a subtle phase effect pedal.
 
Last edited:

etype

Tele-Afflicted
Joined
Sep 23, 2014
Posts
1,949
Location
Dallas
Supposedly the Charlie Christian pickups are very "clean". ANd from what I have read, this comes from low winds of a fat wire around a high powered magnet. I think the Guild Franz pickups are P90s with that same characteristic (but less extreme).

 

yDcwpdNlaz

Friend of Leo's
Joined
Aug 18, 2013
Posts
3,081
Location
*******
What is meant by a "clean sounding guitar?" What's the basis of comparison?

Any guitar with both the volume and tone dimed will let the most "pure" sound into the amp. Take that to the extreme with an EVH-style guitar by wiring up the pickups directly to the jack and taking the volume and tone out of the equation completely. Off the shelf, the best option for something like this would be some kind of Esquire or other single-pickup guitar.

Or, if you're looking for an acoustic sound, a hollow-body would be the answer.
 

IronSchef

Tele-Afflicted
Joined
Mar 12, 2013
Posts
1,103
Location
Flew here on my Dragonfly
My 2003 MIJ Gretsch 1959 Nashville Classic wins the competition, for me.
It has great sounding TV Jones pickups, a neck position Supertron and a bridge position Classic+.
Just love it's clean tone.
Sounds great with a cranked amp, too!

+1 on TVJs - I have a TVJ Classic neck in my Cabronita, that pickup on that guitar sounds better on Ch1 of my SCx2 that ANY of my other guitars do!
 

Danjabellza

Friend of Leo's
Joined
Sep 22, 2014
Posts
2,899
Location
Tacoma, Wa
I bought a strat on Craigslist that had Klein pickups in it. I think it was the epic 54 set... but I could not get those pickups to distort. They stayed clean through my jcm2000 even with the gain cranked, they stayed clean through whatever dirt boxes I had at the time. It was ridiculous.
 

freshchops

Tele-Meister
Joined
Jan 18, 2010
Posts
339
Location
Louisiana-USA
I guess I could elaborated on tones for a reference. I'm trying to get close to guitar tones from 80's pop, new wave, synth wave, etc. Midnight Oil "Beds are Burning" (strummed chords) Ric Ocasek "Emotion in Motion", Men at Work "Down Under" (palm muted parts), Talking Heads / David Byrne, Tears For Fears, the Cure, etc.

There's a lot of chorus in use back in the day. I know Strats come into the picture a lot. I know the Roland Jazz Chorus was commonly used too.

As far as "clean only used to describe amps". Maybe so, but I have a clean BF-TR and a SF-VibroSonic. Each different guitar I plug into it has it's own range and qualities. Some don't stay clean in the lows; some are too bright and brittle or bring out the shrill in the highs. Surely there are guitars that in their own right, are more prone to and iconic for staying clean and articulate across the board.

I'm not surprised to see some of the semi-hollowbodies mentioned. I'm looking into those. I occasionally play a friends Epi Sheraton (330's-ish) with super light gauge strings. That one is mighty clean.

The Klein pickups sound great from their clips and some youtube demos. Guess that's kind of a nod for the strat's too.
 

freshchops

Tele-Meister
Joined
Jan 18, 2010
Posts
339
Location
Louisiana-USA
My 2003 MIJ Gretsch 1959 Nashville Classic wins the competition, for me.
It has great sounding TV Jones pickups, a neck position Supertron and a bridge position Classic+.
Just love it's clean tone.
Sounds great with a cranked amp, too!

I've been thoroughly considering a Gretsch with TV'J's. I'll see if I can spend some time with one through my amps.
 
Top