I've signed on in another "Les Paul Forum", but I haven't been there in ages. It and another forum that talks about Martin guitars seem to have "members only" attitude.
And I'm like, "Dude, I have a '74 Gibson Cherry Sunburst Les Paul Deluxe, isn't that good enough?"
If you don't have a Les Paul Standard, at the very least, they won't even waste their time on you...IMO.
I know the forum of which you speak, and there is a definite hierarchy there, with the Norlin/USA production guys at the bottom of the totem pole, followed by supersubtle gradations through the Gibson Custom Shop models and then through the vintage Gibsons, with the people who own original 1958-1960 Bursts acclaimed as the very pinnacle of musical skill, tone and taste.
We're Not Worthy! (Before anyone dismisses this as sour grapes, I do own a 1956 vintage Les Paul.)
Also, there is a definite Emperor's New Clothes effect there, where members compete to claim to hear the difference between different brands of 500K potentiometers or the singing qualities of "old wood."
I like Les Pauls. I post there occasionally. I am actually not that much of a Tele freak, but I like the much more skeptical and friendly atmosphere around here.