The situation does matter doesn’t it? When playing low volume jams with friends in my living room I like a wider EQ range than when playing in a band situation, with bass and drums.Depends on what either is being used for. Currently I am using a TS Mini to tame my Fuzz Face and boosting duties. Gain on zero volume past unity. I recently bought an old SD-1 because it was $25. I am a big fan of the BD-2 but SD-1 is a classic. We’ll see where it lands.
At that point it makes sense to cut the bass and highs to avoid muddying the mix.