telepraise
Tele-Afflicted
re: sealing before dye- I only do this with light coats super blond shellac, but only on spruce tops because they can get splotchy. I haven't found the need to seal maple.Hi Freeman, unless I'm missing something, I avoided the raised grain issue by pre-raising it. After sanding back the black, I wiped the board with a clean, damp rag. After it was thoroughly dry, I sanded lightly with 320, just enough to remove any fuzz. Then, I applied the red dye stain. I had no issues with raised grain. After the red dried (overnight), I applied the clear coats.
I like your 4-way test. I'll repeat the water vs DNA portion. I'm glad you take the experimental approach, but I'm not surprised sealing before dye didn't work out.
I definitely like the idea of more vibrant color. I keep thinking there's another argument in favor of water-based dye, besides the French polish scenario, but so far I can't remember it.
I take notes as I learn through building, but when it comes to finishing, there are so many variables, I often wish I had taken better notes at the time.
I switched over from analine dies to Transtint several years ago and there is a learning curve as the dyes are intense. For sunbursting I mix the Transtint in a medium of acetone and retarder because I have them already and the retarder gives me more time to move the color around and blend the shades together (see mando above). If you want the traditional REALLY dark around the very edge, it's easier just to shoot it with a detail gun.
I seal in the burst with either shellac or sanding sealer. It's always magic when you put that first coat of clear on the burst.