Nice! Wish I had a Martin. John, do I remember correctly that you made a trip to Nazareth to pick up that guitar?
For my part, my favorite non-Fender guitars are my Logan Custom teles.
I do have one Logan Custom guitar that’s non-tele, Bob Logan’s Challenger model. (Hanging on the right behind the couch.)
I also have a Logan Custom acoustic/electric in tele dimensions, which is my go-to or favorite a/e guitar for gigging purposes. (Hanging on the left behind the couch.)
So, mostly my favorites are my Logans. However, I have one favorite that I’ve had for 38 years, that’s been with me halfway around the world and back, that for 17 years was my only guitar. It’s my MiJ Hohner G-940 dreadnought, bought new in 1983.
Danelectro. That’s the first electric I was obsessed by, and I still own the first one I bought, 35+ years ago. Godin would be my second choice, though. (And to be fair, I don’t actually own a Fender product. A Squier body, yes, but it has a Danelectro neck on it.)