Spaceboy
Tele-Afflicted
The Hotcake was a staple for one of my favorite bands from the '90s. I bought the pedal and it did nothing for me. It was dark and without any real presence. It got the wooly tone I expected, but the bottom end was woofy and without that fuzz-like texture I associated with the pedal. I played it through ten or so amps between my own and a couple buddies, and not one sounded right. So I took it into a shop one day and plugged into an AC30. Within moments I found those tones I had been hearing for years, going through dozens of overdrives and fuzzes in the chase. I bought an AC30 soon after and now it's my primary rig. When people comment about this pedal and amp being a perfect match, they are not overstating. I couldn't get a sound I like from anything other Vox and oddly a JCM800 set to slight crunch. It needs a bright and loud amplifier to really shine.Can't help you with setting suggestions as I don't have one of these pedals but it's possible that the amp and pedal just don't work well together.
I've got a Crowther Hot Cake that many people love but I just can't get it to work with any of my amps in a way that I find good to my ears. The only use I have for it is when I use it as a clean boost.
Actually the Hot Cake was supposedly designed with an AC30 in mind - Paul Crowther was the drummer in Split Enz and Neil Finn used AC30's so that was his test bed apparently.
Might be worth checking out........
If you end up trying an AC30, immediately do the bright cap mod on the top boost channe and use the Hotcake there. It's less stunning on the normal channel, and without the bright cap mod, the top boost game is thin and lifeless and doesn't give you a real impression of what the amp sounds like cranked.