Unpopular Opinions about Guitars

micpoc

Friend of Leo's
Joined
Mar 17, 2007
Posts
4,723
Location
Louisiana
“Guitars are like typewriters. It’s technology, it’s not something to be admired or worshipped. Like, oh, a washing machine or something. It does the job. You start seeing people putting them on walls as decorations and it’s just… it’s like putting a vacuum cleaner there. That’s really bizarre for me. They’re okay; they all sound the same, it’s the brutal truth.”— Jonny Greenwood of Radiohead
 

SixStringSlinger

Poster Extraordinaire
Joined
May 21, 2006
Posts
6,326
Location
Space
Esquires (and other single-pickup guitars) do have an effect on your playing that is, at best, difficult to get from another guitar, not because of some consequence of the guitar's having a single pickup (I'm agnostic about this, and more or less skeptical about our being able to hear any real effect, if it does exist), but because having "no way out" forces the player's mind into dealing with being "stuck" on the one pickup in new and creative ways, which is unlikely to happen on a multi-pickup guitar no matter how sincerely the player resolves to remain on a single pickup.

You also cannot logic your way out of this fact, because the fact itself is not entirely logical.
 

cyclopean

Poster Extraordinaire
Joined
Aug 14, 2009
Posts
8,446
Location
innsmouth, MA
Yeah, but adjust that $300 for inflation and your Mexi suddendly becomes a $600 guitar, doesn't it? And then we're not in the sub $500 category anymore.

Anyway, they're fine on my 2010 FSR Roadworn Tele Deluxe too, whereas this MIC Squier I had wore its frets down in a year. But then the Mexi production has always used better materials and components, because their guitars are more expensive...
Is that actual inflation? What’s a used mexi tele going for these days?
 

cyclopean

Poster Extraordinaire
Joined
Aug 14, 2009
Posts
8,446
Location
innsmouth, MA
Esquires (and other single-pickup guitars) do have an effect on your playing that is, at best, difficult to get from another guitar, not because of some consequence of the guitar's having a single pickup (I'm agnostic about this, and more or less skeptical about our being able to hear any real effect, if it does exist), but because having "no way out" forces the player's mind into dealing with being "stuck" on the one pickup in new and creative ways, which is unlikely to happen on a multi-pickup guitar no matter how sincerely the player resolves to remain on a single pickup.

You also cannot logic your way out of this fact, because the fact itself is not entirely logical.
I’m inclined to doubt that - how many tele players ever use their neck pickup? That thing sounds awful.
 

msalama

Friend of Leo's
Joined
Jul 16, 2021
Posts
2,406
Location
EUnistan
a used mexi tele going for

For about €800 in our neck of the woods, although you can usually haggle that down somewhat. Get a good one for €500 though, and you got yourself a steal. And yes, I do realize they tend to be cheaper Stateside.
 

KelvinS1965

Tele-Afflicted
Joined
Apr 9, 2014
Posts
1,472
Location
Wokingham England
I’m inclined to doubt that - how many tele players ever use their neck pickup? That thing sounds awful.
I use it more than the bridge as I find that awful sometimes, depending on the amp or any pedals used.

Second unpopular opinion: Buying lots of guitars to 'inspire' or otherwise improve your playing doesn't help. Focusing on a single guitar might though; a bit 'anti-guitar forum' though I guess since they're mostly about buying more gear...
 

cyclopean

Poster Extraordinaire
Joined
Aug 14, 2009
Posts
8,446
Location
innsmouth, MA
I use it more than the bridge as I find that awful sometimes, depending on the amp or any pedals used.

Second unpopular opinion: Buying lots of guitars to 'inspire' or otherwise improve your playing doesn't help. Focusing on a single guitar might though; a bit 'anti-guitar forum' though I guess since they're mostly about buying more gear...
A new guitar can jump start you but it gets into diminishing returns pretty fast.
 

middy

Poster Extraordinaire
Joined
Apr 28, 2010
Posts
5,316
Age
52
Location
MSP
Oh, I thought it was $5,400. Uh, so the difference between a $150 guitar and a $600 guitar is also marketing then, too. I think I get the logic now after all these years. Yeah, "Marketing". Thanks for clearing things up! 😂

Wait a minute.....Do the vintage guys know of this?
The vintage guys are the best at marketing.
"Oh my God! The heavenly experience of playing this '55 Tele with the sticky nitro neck and the microphonic pickups and weird wiring scheme and dark neck pickup and way out of spec capacitor! It smells like a barroom in heaven!"
 
Top