To Bigsby or not?

  • Thread starter SlimGrady
  • Start date
  • This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links like Ebay, Amazon, and others.

dlew919

Doctor of Teleocity
Silver Supporter
Joined
Aug 6, 2012
Posts
12,419
Location
Sydney
I haven't had personal experience with a Bigsby that stayed in tune - maybe I've never played a high end one. I vote for whatever doesn't require you to drill holes
Clearly I don’t know your experience. And you may have tried all of this but bigsby needs a properly cut and lubricated nut and saddles. And at least 10s. And 11s or higher are better. Mine stay in tune. Mostly.
 

CalebAaron666

Tele-Afflicted
Joined
Dec 2, 2018
Posts
1,161
Location
Auburn, Maine
Go Bigsby or go home!
If it were me, I’d commit fully with a B7, forgo the vibramate, and slap the classic “custom made” badge over the old tailpiece holes.
55B861B7-0A36-4E41-891F-B16D5193BB28.jpeg


Or use a B6 and a Towner Bar.
It’d definitely be more functional than a B7.
Like this:
60FFED6D-832D-46F8-94D5-D357957CE591.jpeg
 
Last edited:

BobWithOneO

TDPRI Member
Joined
Oct 13, 2021
Posts
80
Age
47
Location
Best Carolina
Find a B6 made in 'murrica. I have one on my Epiphone Joe Pass and it gives that spongy buttercream feel. It's far out man. Put some booby tassels on the post holes from the current bridge and live with it. You know you want to or you wouldn't have started the thread.
 

dlew919

Doctor of Teleocity
Silver Supporter
Joined
Aug 6, 2012
Posts
12,419
Location
Sydney
For some reason a lot of people seem to hate the B7. I don’t know why but it might be worth checking out if it’s an ‘angry internet’ thing or if there’s a actual reason.
 

hemingway

Doctor of Teleocity
Joined
Mar 14, 2012
Posts
12,356
Location
London, UK
Regardless of which vibrato you choose, the question to ask yourself is, how much am I really going to use it?

I have wiggle sticks on two of my guitars. Would never miss them if they weren't there.
 

JetTech582

Tele-Afflicted
Joined
Jan 24, 2022
Posts
1,380
Age
16
Location
Muskegon MI
Well, I'd say no to the bigsby
and yes to the vibramate. If you ever want to sell it, just take off the bigsby and use it again on a different guitar
 

Boreas

Telefied
Ad Free Member
Joined
Nov 3, 2019
Posts
20,703
Age
70
Location
Adirondack Coast, NY
Regardless of which vibrato you choose, the question to ask yourself is, how much am I really going to use it?

I have wiggle sticks on two of my guitars. Would never miss them if they weren't there.

I am just the opposite. I use "shimmer" a lot and always find myself grabbing for a Bigsby arm if it isn't there. But yes, if you have one guitar with a trem but never use it, doesn't make much sense to add another.
 
Last edited:

SlimGrady

Tele-Meister
Joined
Aug 28, 2021
Posts
413
Age
28
Location
Kentucky
Regardless of which vibrato you choose, the question to ask yourself is, how much am I really going to use it?

I have wiggle sticks on two of my guitars. Would never miss them if they weren't there.
I don’t own a single guitar with a vibrato on it. And something about playing a semi hollow and big chords makes you really miss having something.
I have dealt with bigsby’s in the past on gretsch guitars I have owned. Never had the problems I hear of people keeping them in tune. And I just miss having something in the Arsenal with the wiggle stick on it.

This 335 is a life goal guitar for me and I lucked up and got one that is perfect. So I don’t mind permanently mounting something to it if it will enhance the guitar in some way.
 

Boreas

Telefied
Ad Free Member
Joined
Nov 3, 2019
Posts
20,703
Age
70
Location
Adirondack Coast, NY
For some reason a lot of people seem to hate the B7. I don’t know why but it might be worth checking out if it’s an ‘angry internet’ thing or if there’s a actual reason.

Simple - there are two types of Bigsbys - tension bar and non-tension bar. Tension bars add friction and make the system feel stiff and not as articulate. On a guitar that allows a choice (archtop) I would always choose the unit without the tension roller. There are some user-mods that smooth out the rollers somewhat, but to me, the ultimate Bigsby is unfettered to the saddles.

The other issue related to friction is tuning stability. This isn't string-to-string stability (usually NUT related), but all of the strings not returning to pitch after a dive or lift. The traditional "US" made models aren't too bad because of metal alloy (bronze?) bushings, but the "licensed" models with tension bars fitted with nylon bushings may as well be called "friction bars". These are the B50/70 models commonly fitted to less expensive guitars and sold by the thousands as add-on units. The simple modification of removing the bushings and replacing them with $1 ball bearings eliminates the tuning instability issue on these models - and even Chigsbys.

I believe the "licensed" models and improper setup techniques are the source of much Bigsby hate. Try to play guitars with both styles before you decide to determine which FEEL you prefer, as it often dictates how you use the Bigsby.
 
Last edited:

dlew919

Doctor of Teleocity
Silver Supporter
Joined
Aug 6, 2012
Posts
12,419
Location
Sydney
Simple - there are two types of Bigsbys - tension bar and non-tension bar. Tension bars add friction and make the system feel stiff and not as articulate. On a guitar that allows a choice (archtop) I would always choose the unit without the tension roller. There are some user-mods that smooth out the rollers somewhat, but to me, the ultimate Bigsby is unfettered to the saddles.

The other issue related to friction is tuning stability. This isn't string-to-string stability (usually nut related), but all of the strings not returning to pitch after a dive or lift. The traditional "US" made models aren't too bad because of metal alloy (bronze?) bushings, but the "licensed" models with tension bars fitted with nylon bushings may as well be called "friction bars". These are the B50/70 models commonly fitted to less expensive guitars and sold by the thousands as add-on units. The simple modification of removing the bushings and replacing them with $1 ball bearings eliminates the tuning instability issue.

I believe the "licensed" models and improper setup techniques are the source of much Bigsby hate. Try to play guitars with both styles before you decide to determine which FEEL you prefer, as it often dictates how you use the Bigsby.
Thanks for that. I now understand! :)
 

Boreas

Telefied
Ad Free Member
Joined
Nov 3, 2019
Posts
20,703
Age
70
Location
Adirondack Coast, NY
I don’t own a single guitar with a vibrato on it. And something about playing a semi hollow and big chords makes you really miss having something.
I have dealt with bigsby’s in the past on gretsch guitars I have owned. Never had the problems I hear of people keeping them in tune. And I just miss having something in the Arsenal with the wiggle stick on it.

This 335 is a life goal guitar for me and I lucked up and got one that is perfect. So I don’t mind permanently mounting something to it if it will enhance the guitar in some way.

It definitely changes how you approach the instrument. The type of Bigsby you choose will go a long way to determining how. The B7 will feel a little stiffer but something that invites Neil Young type of abuse. The B3/B6 would be a more subtle, jazzier, surf-style shimmer. This may help you decide which model you want to add. But you DO need a guitar with a Bigsby!! Everyone does!
 

scottser

Friend of Leo's
Joined
Mar 6, 2009
Posts
4,989
Location
dublin
i wouldn't put a bigsby on that guitar for love nor money. but if you absolutely must, then use a vibromate.
 

hdvades

Tele-Afflicted
Joined
Mar 6, 2016
Posts
1,535
Age
65
Location
Hudson Valley, NY
I'd just wait for a Vibamate. I have an old LP that has a std Bigsby. Whoever did the work did a good job plugging the holes...the plugs could be removed if I ever chose. It can be done. Good luck. Sweet 335.

"That's what I think too - adding a Bigsby opens the tone up - something a Vibrate doesn't do."
ps...I didn't know that.
 

Boreas

Telefied
Ad Free Member
Joined
Nov 3, 2019
Posts
20,703
Age
70
Location
Adirondack Coast, NY
B7s seem to make 335s (and maybe all guitars) sound better to me. I would permanently mount a B7 on it. No vibramate. Brass plugs in the post holes.
My theory on this is that hollow and semi-hollow guitars often lack the strong sustain that many solid bodies have. With vibrato provided by fingers or a whammy, it tends to prolong the note(s) longer, creating a little more sustain. But that is just a theory.

On some instruments, the vibration of the strings is absorbed and dampened by the vibrato and its springs. You can feel it in the bar. But on others, that vibration actually seems to sustained by the spring. This is just an observation - cannot explain why one enhances and the other deadens. Likely has to do with the dominant resonances of each guitar and trem system.
 

Freeman Keller

Doctor of Teleocity
Ad Free Member
Joined
Aug 22, 2018
Posts
15,880
Age
80
Location
Washington
I'll add one other comment. I will install a Bigsby or other trem if someone wants it, as the red guitar in my previous post. But I have also removed them for people who don't want or like them. Here is a little semi hollow that a friend bought and didn't like, I simply put a tail piece on and plugged the mounting holes. He can always reinstall the Bigsby if he wants

IMG_6294.JPG
 
Last edited:
Top