The Beatles - Doctor Robert

  • Thread starter ping-ping-clicka
  • Start date
  • This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links like Ebay, Amazon, and others.

jrblue

Friend of Leo's
Joined
Nov 14, 2010
Posts
4,148
Location
Santa Barbara
Heck, yeah. Between the unusual guitar tones and genuinely strange riffs, that's an incredible tune. It's like a mini-symphony with the radically different movements. Yet pure pop, too.
 

getbent

Tele Axpert
Ad Free Member
Joined
Mar 2, 2006
Posts
53,442
Location
San Benito County, California
Dr. Robert is such a great song... super clean AND elegantly messy too... great tones, great harmony... just a killer, sounds as fresh today as when it was recorded.

I remember seeing Andrew Gold at the Roxy years ago (when he first went solo) and his third encore was Dr. Robert and it was done perfectly... they had great singers in his band and the harmonies were really great....

thanks for posting!
 

Telecaster88

Friend of Leo's
Joined
May 9, 2019
Posts
2,528
Age
56
Location
Midwest USA
I was just listening to this album again yesterday, and having grown up on the US version, the presence of all the missing Lennon tunes is still a little jarring to me...

It's an alright song, but to my ears it's the only track on Revolver that isn't groundbreaking. It would have fit in better with the Rubber Soul tunes. For this reason, I always liked it more in the Yesterday and Today sequence.

(Don't hate me! I'm still the Beatles' #1 Fan!)
 

Mike M

Friend of Leo's
Joined
Dec 20, 2019
Posts
2,740
Location
07040
I was just listening to this album again yesterday, and having grown up on the US version, the presence of all the missing Lennon tunes is still a little jarring to me...

It's an alright song, but to my ears it's the only track on Revolver that isn't groundbreaking. It would have fit in better with the Rubber Soul tunes. For this reason, I always liked it more in the Yesterday and Today sequence.

(Don't hate me! I'm still the Beatles' #1 Fan!)

The Beatles left nothing on the cutting room floor with their releases.

They weren't the kind of artists who had tons of outtakes they could choose from. The used every scrap they had.

Their EMI contract demanded 2 full UK albums (around 13-14 songs each) and 3 singles a year (an additional 6 songs).

That's 36 songs needed a year, so it comes out to about a new song (very little covers at this point) every 10 days.

For Rubber Soul, it meant using everything they had, including fake songs from their youth they used to pick up girls in the Art School Cafeteria, when Paul and George came to visit John (Michelle).

For Revolver, it meant making something out of songs that basically only had one chord (Tomorrow Never Knows)

Brian Epstein would usually schedule them off of work (touring, appearances) for 10-14 days to write all the songs for the new album. Paul and John would think they "had it made" to have two weeks off. :)

Unbelievable by todays standards.
 

String Tree

Telefied
Joined
Dec 8, 2010
Posts
20,957
Location
Up North
It's important to remember that the public didn't know the backstory when this song came out. They could guess, but they didn't know for sure.

According to Ringo, it's about touring in northern England on a Bus with no Privy.
John had to make do behind a seat.
Upset Paul terribly.
 
Top