Tele nightmare

TelePlayer_Ruben

TDPRI Member
Ad Free Member
Joined
Sep 2, 2022
Posts
24
Location
U.S.
I cannot believe this happened to me!

I recently moved to Maryland for work. After a few months of living here, I noticed my Tele had developed pretty bad fret sprout (Fret ends were protruding from the edge of the fingerboard) and was no longer comfortable to play. I thought about fixing up the frets myself as I have done other repairs on my guitar. However, I did not want to risk messing the frets up, so I decided to take my guitar to a professional. I brought my guitar into the shop and let the guy know it had fret sprout. The guy's response was "Fret what? Fret Sprout? I never heard of it." So, I showed him what I was talking about, and he proceeded to annotate what needed to be done and told me it will be ready in a few days.

Four days later (Today), I go to pick up the guitar, and notice the frets felt the same. I took a closer look and realized not only were the frets still protruding, but they were worse than before and the wood around the frets was chipped along almost every fret. Some chips were deeper than others. On top of that, the tops of the frets were no longer smooth but gripping the string if you tried to bend the string!!! My wife was there, she does not play guitar, but even she could see how bad of a job he did.

I inform the employee who was going to ring me up for the work (The guy who did the fret job was not in today), and his words were "yes, you are definitely not paying for this. Let me speak to the manager." I'm glad they realized it was a very poor job and didn't try to defend the work!

After about an hour, the place ended up placing an order for a replacement neck for me that should be arriving in about 3 - 5 days free of charge for me ($450). I'm pretty bummed out that my guitar will no longer have the original neck, but I guess I will hold onto it if I ever decide to sell the guitar in the future. The guitar is a Fender Road Worn 50's Telecaster. I added some photos for you to see.

AND I just realized the Low E string is not ringing freely. I hope nothing is wrong with the bridge!!! I'll have to do a proper set up once I receive the new neck and ensure everything is still okay with the bridge.

Has anyone had a similar experience? If so, did it motivate you to learn to do the work on your own guitars?

tele 2.jpeg
tele neck 1.jpeg
 

Speedy454

Tele-Holic
Joined
Oct 1, 2013
Posts
662
Location
Highland, IL
That work is just plain horrible. At least the shop is buying you a replacement neck. The person who did that 'work' is nothing but a hack, and should never touch a stringed instrument again. I hat saying people should get fired, but that person needs to find a different line of work. They obviously do not play, otherwise they never would have done that.
 

TelePlayer_Ruben

TDPRI Member
Ad Free Member
Joined
Sep 2, 2022
Posts
24
Location
U.S.
Wow. That's royally screwed up. Glad you're getting a replacement. I haven't (yet) had to deal with sprout or incompetent luthiers/techs, but I'm sure someone will post a horror story. Something like this would encourage me to learn how to do it myself.
It has definitely encouraged me to learn more about these types of repairs.
 

jrblue

Friend of Leo's
Joined
Nov 14, 2010
Posts
3,681
Location
Santa Barbara
Wow! It's awfully hard to believe that anyone with any awareness of what a guitar is, and how it is played, would hack things up like that. They would have to be drunk or high, or maybe handed it off to someone else who did it. It's really unbelievable. But it is the shop's responsibility and I'm glad they are replacing the neck.
 

TelePlayer_Ruben

TDPRI Member
Ad Free Member
Joined
Sep 2, 2022
Posts
24
Location
U.S.
Wow! It's awfully hard to believe that anyone with any awareness of what a guitar is, and how it is played, would hack things up like that. They would have to be drunk or high, or maybe handed it off to someone else who did it. It's really unbelievable. But it is the shop's responsibility and I'm glad they are replacing the neck.
I was almost speechless! How could anyone in their right mind finish the job, look it over, and say "yup I'm done, let me inform the customer is ready for pickup!"
 

TelePlayer_Ruben

TDPRI Member
Ad Free Member
Joined
Sep 2, 2022
Posts
24
Location
U.S.
Answering the question in this post - I have trust issues, I'm cheap, and enjoy working with my hands and figuring stuff out.

Guessing these may be common personality traits of guitar techs everywhere, not sure... :D
Great traits I may have to practice from this point on!
 

Freeman Keller

Doctor of Teleocity
Joined
Aug 22, 2018
Posts
11,183
Age
78
Location
Washington
I do work, not only on my own guitars but for several of the local musicians. There were several red flags in your story (and of course I'm only hearing one side) but a setup tech should know how to deal with sharp fret ends, it is one of the most common repaires I deal with during the winter.

However that can be complicated by working on a finished maple fretboard- I've quit doing it except for special friends. I've completely stopped refretting finished boards - someone else can have the hassle and the big bucks

If you want to learn how to deal with frets and do setups you might find this helpful


And you can avoid the need to file sharp fret ends by keeping your guitar humidified
 

Wallaby

Friend of Leo's
Joined
Feb 19, 2018
Posts
3,751
Location
Here
It helps to have a plan. Spend plenty of time researching, reading, thinking, pondering, etc. This forum is a wonderful resource; also check out Ted Woodford on Youtube ( among others I can't remember ATM ).

Then make a purchasing spreadsheet and fill it with every tool you'll need, including vendor, SKU #'s, cost, URL's, everything.

Then you can methodically start ordering what you need. Or just order it all at once if you have ready cash. But it beats the "Home Depot" syndrome of always forgetting that one thing and going back later.

I'll definitely be learning how to do fret work. I guess on the upside is now I have a neck to practice on!
 
Top