Smaller board, keep two of these ODs...

Amp would be nice to know, but for my uses it would be the Tumnus to thicken things up and the TS9 to cut through for leads.

 

This^^^^

 

Never liked what a Klone offered, gimme the BD and the TS!

 

Not familiar with the (lauded, it seems) Waza options, but IMO a Blues Driver is a helluva good tool. Lot of range it those 3 knobs.

 

Tumnus, Ts9 (analogman mod)

 

I have tried to like the TS several times but for me, it lops off too much bottom end in my opinion. Therefore, I would go with the Blues Driver and Tumnus as a boost/lead tone. YMMV.

I’m currently running a King of Tone (bluesbreaker clone) and Aion FX (Klon clone) and couldn’t be happier.

 

Tumnus and TS9. Run the Tumnus before to add grit and overdrive the amp, and then the TS9 for lead sounds. Or swap and use the Tumnus as a volume boost for solos.

I have a Keeley-modded TS9 on my smaller travel setup and have gain at 7-8 o'clock and volume at 4-5 o'clock - then it's pushing the amp vs. generating the overdrive on its own.

 

A Blues Driver surely....A TS surely not

 

I'd keep the BD and the Tumnus for playing at home. For playing in a band mix it depends on the amp.

 

I don’t find that the Tumnus sounds anything like a Klon even though I know it’s supposed to. I’d take it and the Blues Driver. TS is just thin, weak, overdone and boring to me.

Capgun

 

Seems like those are three pedals that cover similar territory. For a small board I’d pick the BD-2 and something heavier. Maybe, hmm... a Rat? Actually on my board right now I’ve got a BD-2 and an Xotic SL Drive; that’s working really well for me.

 

Had all three of those, got rid of two.
Can’t tell you which the keeper was though. It’s pointless without telling you my amps, guitars, and what I play.

 

I’d keep the Boss and tube screamer. The Tumnus should sell well. The BD2 gets a nice rhythm sound and the TS has the mid boost.

 

Standard BD-2 and be done with it, or an SD-1 if the amp is scooped. I find klons and TS pedals kinda meh, and the only overdrives I've ever preferred to Boss effects are J. Rockett pedals (which are 3x the price).

 

Keep the Tumnus and whichever of the other two suits your repertoire the best.

 

Tumnus as always on pedal - klons just add some nice secret sauce

BD-2W, custom mode. I prefer a bit more low end, but this will do...

 

I'd go with the Tumnus and TS. I've never been a fan of the BD2. It gets way too fuzzy and fizzy with the gain and sustain level that I like. If I have to keep the gain down to eliminate the fizz, then I don't want it. And, I'd much rather have a Timmy type or a Bluesbreaker type for an OD without a mid-hump, neither of which will get fizzy when the gain is turned up.