Small tube amps for home studio/DAW use

Even though I use a modeler, I have been thinking "why doesn't someone make a DAW-oriented tube amp", and I guess they do!

Crawling out from under my rock, I just have become aware of these amps:

Revv D20:
https://www.sweetwater.com/store/detail/RevvD20--revv-d20-20-4-watt-tube-head

Mesa Boogie Mark V:25
https://www.mesaboogie.com/amplifiers/electric/mark-series/mark-five-25/1x10-combo.html

Friedman Runt 20:
https://www.sweetwater.com/store/detail/Runt20Head--friedman-runt-20-20-watt-tube-head

These look like they could be pretty crazy for real tube and XLR->DAW use. And even listening to through a guitar cab!

Cab sims
The Rev D20 includes DSP for both IRs and room reverbs, and as far as I can tell, they also offer the ability to model different power amp tubes if you are using the direct out. Front panel knob selects 1 of 6 preset IRs and MIDI can select even more (which seems really unnecessary to me, but whatever).
Mesa and Friedman are both analog cab simulation IIRC
Mesa has closed back/mic angle switches.
Friedman has a mic position switch.

Channels
Revv appears to have two programmable channels available.
Mesa has two different foot switchable channels with different preamps.
Friedman appears to just have one channel.

Sounds
The Revv D20 seems more geared to clean/crunch sounds
The Boogie looks really cool too! Like the sounds on that one. A bit on the complicated side.
Friedman is OK clean, seems tilted towards high gain.

Programming:
Revv includes Two Notes Torpedo load/IR processing, PC/Mac apps, etc. Seems pretty flexible, and the expense of being more complicated. I'm not always hot on having a PC to mess with the guitar box. Supports MIDI, presets, etc. I'm not sure if the voices are fully programmable or not.
Mesa has a dedicated second preamp channel.

Using something like these would be an interesting change, mostly because these are not "modeling" anything, they are just "being" something, and they don't have integrated effects and an easy (built-in) way to manage a ton of presets. So, whatever guitar I grab, I dial in the sound then and there, hope for the best when recording it, then add FX in the DAW (although they all have mono FX loops).

On all of these I am leaning towards the Revv. It's more oriented to clean/crunch which I think is great. I don't know what to do with a lot of gain most of the time.

 

That one looks really cool too! Not sure I'm enamored of the class A sound BUT... has great range.

 

I don't currently own a tube amp which is why I'm curious about these. I also have a very small space to set things up and the idea of an integrated unit is pretty attractive. I'm not even particularly unhappy with using the modeler. I'm mostly curious if having something like this would entice me to change the way I work. I keep thinking that "simpler is better" and these have fewer options than the modeler, at the expense of some things I'd put right back in such as reverb, tremolo, delay.

 

The Fryette Valvulator GP/DI is interesting and kinda weird at the same time. It includes both DI (buffered from the input) and amped/cab sim XLR outputs, which is interesting because you could track a dry signal all the time in the event you wanted to "re-amp" later. Re-amping to me is getting a bit complicated, but in reality, after doing some recording sessions where I didn't keep close track of which modeler preset I was using, or because I changed that sound along the way, might be something worth exploring.

My Eleven Rack USB output apparently already supports DI and re-amping but I haven't tried that because AFAIK if you are using ASIO drivers you can only have one ASIO device active at a time, so it would involved switching back and forth from the 11R to my Behringer XR18 mixer. And setting the 11R to re-amp involves reading the manual, etc. etc. I mean MAYBE I will get to where I think it's worth the time.

The Fryette also has an effects return for the headphones only, which strikes me as a bit of an odd choice. I do track with some reverb on almost always, so I can see that, but not having the ability to insert effects prior to the XLR/cab sim is slightly odd. I still find it... intriguing.

I think the Mesa is verging on too complicated, and the Laney... looks "fascinating" as well... sort of a unique voice with the class A business. I think class A overdrive can sound "congested" for lack of a better term, from the even harmonics. Is it bad? Not really.

So much to think about!

 

I am developing GAS pangs on this Fryette GP/DI. One thing I like about it is that it's all analog. The cab sim has some adjustments but they seem more like "more/less mid" or "more/less treble". Honestly I can't relate to most IR based cab/mic sims because I don't know what to expect so I dial them up and go "hmmmmm". I know all the demo guys KNOW they want a 4x12 with a 421 condensor ahead of time, but I don't. Being able to dial something like that in is really attractive to me.

Edit - looks like there is a new model which can load IRs! I guess that's OK

The TwoNotes Torpedo business in the Revv D20 is interesting, esp. considering it includes some reverbs, but that is pushing towards the "more complicated/more options/more crap to fiddle with instead of writing a song".

The Fryette is rendered even more enticing by the fact that YOU CAN'T BUY ONE RIGHT NOW. Maybe through distribution, but direct sales are out of stock for awhile "because of". Nobody's selling one on Reverb either! So that means either:
a) People who have them don't want to let them go
b) They never really sold any to begin with
c) Everybody's just trying to make me mad!

Anyone have one? How do you use it? Is good?

 

I already have an Eleven Rack which works fine. I dunno... I just want to do my part for the US economy or something? And part of it is also that in all my years I've never owned a TOOB AMP, and y'know, time's a-wasting and I don't want to be sitting there at the end thinking "maybe THAT's why I never became a world famous rock and roll star???" Silly stuff like that. Everything's got tradeoffs.