Mellow yet clear Tele pickups

  • Thread starter Lonn
  • Start date
  • This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links like Ebay, Amazon, and others.

Lonn

Poster Extraordinaire
Joined
Dec 13, 2007
Posts
7,201
Age
63
Location
Indiana
What in your opinion is a good set of mellow, lower output pickups that are still clear? Not bright…….clear. My MIJ Tele (avatar) is a fabulous guitar but the stock “traditional” pickups are a bit harsh sounding for my taste.
 

Whoa Tele

Friend of Leo's
Joined
Mar 20, 2009
Posts
2,985
Location
Smyrna Ga.
I like filtertrons in a tele for what you’re describing . For traditional tele pickups A3 magnets sound a little softer To my ears . I also use the middle position more than most tele players I know
 

Saarlaender

TDPRI Member
Joined
Mar 31, 2024
Posts
85
Location
Saarland
Hi.Before investing money in pickups try pure nickel strings/coated ones like the blue from Elixir and or an equalizer. Less expensive and mostly works. And you can try it out beforehand. If the pickups are installed and they don't fit, that's not good either. It´s up to you. Good luck.
 

archetype

Fiend of Leo's
Joined
Jun 4, 2005
Posts
11,525
Location
Western NY
What in your opinion is a good set of mellow, lower output pickups that are still clear? Not bright…….clear. My MIJ Tele (avatar) is a fabulous guitar but the stock “traditional” pickups are a bit harsh sounding for my taste.

If you want to keep it all Fender, IMO the '62 Custom Telecaster set is the ticket. The DCR is somewhat low and they use A3 mags. They can twang, but it's not super bright and the top end is slightly rolled off. Twist the tone knob until your ears and brain say "that's mellow."

An absolute bargain compared to most Fender pickups. Darren Riley usually has them, as well as a ton of Amazon vendors who copy incorrect descriptions from each other, especially stating them as A2 mags, which they don't have.

The steal of a deal is the bridge and pickup assembly. A 60's 3-saddle bridge and bridge pickup. I can't explain why that assembly and the individual pickups are priced relatively low.
 

hopdybob

Friend of Leo's
Joined
May 28, 2008
Posts
3,641
Location
netherlands
i think the microcoil set from Wild Bill & Becky Lawrence with adjustable pole pieces would be an option.
Not noiseless but very noise free and dynamic if your playing is ;)
 

robt57

Telefied
Joined
Feb 29, 2004
Posts
26,964
Location
Portland, OR
Seymour Duncan Alnico IIs round out the high end quite a bit without sounding muddy. FIVE-TWOs are sorta in between.
^^

Lower them 1st thing, especially B/E side of the bridge PU. Also, if neck is a nickle cover, put on a brass chromed cover or another PU with non nickle cover. I do not recall what the MIJ neck cover tend to be, brass or nickle. If orig PUs that is..

Check the POTs to make sure they are 250k, some of my fav Fender PUs are RI MIJ Floral/Paisley FWIW. You can also stop putting fresh strings on and use nickle and let them be oxidized. I actually really like dirty strings with/when lower output PUs.
I really like 5/2s but if you're not thinking your B/E strings are too bright, they prob are not going to change much in the context.

SD Alnico 2s seem like decent chance of your quest.
 

Blue Bill

Doctor of Teleocity
Joined
Feb 15, 2014
Posts
11,330
Location
Maine
You may want to look into Charlie Christian style pickups. They are known for their clarity and mellowness:

 

Supertwang

Tele-Afflicted
Joined
Aug 10, 2014
Posts
1,412
Location
Indiana
I’m treble sensitive and I find it necessary to steer clear of pickups with A5 magnets for that reason….especially true with humbuckers. So far it seems to me A3 in the neck pickup and A2 in the bridge pickup brings a reliable smile. A3 has a low clear jazzy output and A2 is a little hotter with a more old timey Rockabilly voice.
 

guitarsophist

Friend of Leo's
Silver Supporter
Joined
Nov 6, 2016
Posts
2,910
Location
SoCal
I have a Dimarzio Area T (stacked) in the neck and a Dimarzio FastTrack T (dual rails) in the bridge of my MiM Tele. I put in 500K pots, so they are very clear and bright (not harsh), but easily tamed with the tone control. This track features the neck pickup. the backing track is my own:


This track features the FastTrack T bridge. It is a backing track created by @Mjark over on Twanger Central:



I am very happy with these pickups and they may do what you want.
 

Stubee

Doctor of Teleocity
Joined
Jan 22, 2007
Posts
13,717
Location
Mid-Michigan
If you want to keep it all Fender, IMO the '62 Custom Telecaster set is the ticket. The DCR is somewhat low and they use A3 mags. They can twang, but it's not super bright and the top end is slightly rolled off. Twist the tone knob until your ears and brain say "that's mellow."

An absolute bargain compared to most Fender pickups. Darren Riley usually has them, as well as a ton of Amazon vendors who copy incorrect descriptions from each other, especially stating them as A2 mags, which they don't have.

The steal of a deal is the bridge and pickup assembly. A 60's 3-saddle bridge and bridge pickup. I can't explain why that assembly and the individual pickups are priced relatively low.
Agree 100%!!
 

Boreas

Telefied
Ad Free Member
Joined
Nov 3, 2019
Posts
20,703
Age
70
Location
Adirondack Coast, NY
If you can't massage your current pickups by adjusting the heights or changing strings mentioned above, I am partial to Fender PV64 pickups. I have two sets of them. But my others are standard Squier pickups that work well for me. I find the PV64s mellow, but with enough "stuff" behind them that they don't get muddy. They stay quite "clear" as you say, without being harsh. They speak with authority, not a megaphone.
 

Alaska Mike

Tele-Afflicted
Joined
Apr 16, 2021
Posts
1,175
Age
55
Location
Anchorage, AK
So, going off what was said above and adding a little.

I generally start with Fender recommendations for pickup height as a starting place and then adjust from there. Just gives me a baseline.

Saddle material can affect the attack of a pickup.

Pots and caps definitely can affect the tone. I stick with the same 250K pots/.047 cap for pretty much all of my single coils, just to provide a level playing field.

I love the Fender AVRI '62s, but they have some bite- especially with steel bridge saddles. Brass saddles seem to tame them a bit. I have them in four Telecasters currently.

I also love the Fender PV '64s. Smoother and fuller than the AVRI '62s, but with a lot of clarity. I have them in two Telecasters at the moment.

On the boutique side, I have had good luck with Lollar and Fralin. While I respect the products from Bootstrap and Cavalier, I haven't found a voice from them I completely like (yet). I like tinkering, so I swap pickups periodically just out of curiosity if nothing else.
 

Lonn

Poster Extraordinaire
Joined
Dec 13, 2007
Posts
7,201
Age
63
Location
Indiana
Appreciate all the suggestions. I picked it up again yesterday after playing a few of my strats and I guess it doesn’t sound as harsh as I thought, not really harsh at all to be honest so maybe my ears are playing with me. No changes coming for now.
 
Top