Can anybody compare the two? Any other recommendations? I'm looking for a slightly hotter pickup that still retains much of the classic Tele sound. Thanks.
I have Blues Specials in an Esquire, and also in a Highway 1 Tele. They are great pickups, and sound great clean and overdriven. They are not HOT pickups, and thus always sound like a tele to me. The Lollar Special is a little hotter wound, and approaches a quasi P-90 sound with more mids and a smoother tone. I would say it is less tele-like than the Blues Special. Although, with a roll back of the volume knob you can get more of the tele twang.
They are both great pickups. It will really come down to what tones you are after, and the interaction between the pickups, you, your guitar, and amp.
I ended up using the Fralin Blues Specials in a couple of guitars for a little more grind. For my slightly more old school tele/esquire I installed a Lollar Vintage bridge. Both pickups can cover clean to overdriven very well. As long as a pickup isn't brutally bright with a particular amp, I stay away from over-wound pickups. I find it much easier to dial out treble, than to dial out muddy mids.
Thanks sidneystreet. I thought the Lollar Special T was hotter than the Fralin Blues Special but I wasn't sure. The Fralin BS seem to be more of what I'm looking for. Doesn't Lollar make anything that's only slightly hotter than vintage?