Jason Isbell sig Telecaster review

SolaStrings

NEW MEMBER!
Joined
Jan 17, 2023
Posts
2
Location
Central Washington
I haven’t seen a thread dedicated to reviews of the JI Tele, just comparing and complaining on other threads. So, here it is - the official JI Tele review thread. I’ll go first…

Overall, it’s a super cool guitar, especially if, like me, you’re a sucker for bound Tele’s. This one is double-bound, so double the awesome. It’s also got the nitro finish, and who can balk at that? I’m fact, that’s really what convinced me to get this model. After all, if all I wanted was a nice double-bound Tele I’d have gotten the Squier CV.

Other great features of this guitar are:

The pickups. Some of the best I’ve heard. In fact, probably my favorite of all Tele pups.

The neck. Also nitro and feels like a broke in baseball glove. Not too chunky either, which I prefer (my other favorite neck is a soft-v roasted maple Strat, if that’s any indication of my preferences - both 7.25 radius).

The cons:

The price. Get a used one. $1600 is outrageous for a MIM.

The frets. The 14th fret was so high the thing just shut down. Did a quick fix on that just so I could play it, but had to do a fret level and crown to really get it to where it should be. I think some of the frets were intentionally flattened for the road-worn effect, but it was actually quite annoying (and expensive if someone doesn’t have the ability to do the work themselves)

The nut. The low E slot was cut a whole string-width too close to the edge (see pic). I didn’t notice it until I was playing and the E string kept sliding off the frets. I contacted Fender about it, and they offered to fix it under warranty, but the closest location was two hours away. It was cheaper for me to buy a vintage style bone nut from Fender and fix it myself (again, could be costly for someone unable to do that level of work themselves).

Some preference things:

The tuning machines were not road-worn, so I replaced them with some that were. Not sure why Fender didn’t do that to begin with.

The backplate. Not a huge thing, but I prefer the “F” over the JI tattoo.

The saddles. I replaced them with Gotoh compensated saddles.

I also put a black top hat switch cover and a white pickguard on it, but that’s totally preference.

Also, I played a JI Tele at a guitar shop before I got this one, and I can say for sure the neck profile was different (the other one was thicker) and the setup was so bad it was unplayable. Also, the wood grain is a crapshoot. I got a really good one, but I’ve seen some I’d return if I bought sight unseen. Also, the relic level seems to vary as well. Just some things to be aware of.

The big question: is it worth it. Yes, but with major caveats. I scored mine as a return (I know why!) from Adorama for $999 AND I have the tools and know-how to fix the issues Fender QC let this guitar get out the door with. So, worth it for me, yes. Same guitar at full price bought by someone without some luthier skill, no. At that price point, buy a U.S. model with better QC.
 

Attachments

  • 320C606F-1E36-48E5-83D4-6066517AC53F.jpeg
    320C606F-1E36-48E5-83D4-6066517AC53F.jpeg
    140.9 KB · Views: 228

RobRiggs

Friend of Leo's
Joined
Jul 8, 2015
Posts
2,188
Location
Calunicornia
Dang! That’s the worst cut nut I’ve seen on a Fender. Thanks for taking the time to review. Definitely on my want list of Telecasters.
 

Peteurre

Tele-Meister
Joined
Oct 25, 2008
Posts
112
Age
41
Location
Denmark
I'll go second then:
I have wanted one for months, and even though I'm not too keen on signature guitars, I must admit that my love for Jason Isbell's music and guitar playing definitely made the guitar catch my attention. But it was also a matter of really digging my own '73 Tele for the past 6 months, way more than I have in the previous 14 years of owning it, that made me want to buy more Tellies! And the Isbell ticked all the boxes: Nitro, light relic, the Stratty neck pickup, 7,25 inch radius, narrow tall frets...And especially the price. Might be very high for a made in Mexico, but still a lot cheaper than MIA and Custom Shop.

I got one used, for about 75% of the price of a new one, and even though the previous owner had the shop fix a bit of fret sprouts, I've actually ended up handing it over to my favorite luthier (who is aguably one of, if not THE best in my country), because the neck relief was not perfect (and I didn't have the right tool), and it seemed to still need leveling of some of the frets near the body. Furthermore the luthier said, that the nut was so low, that he might have to install a new one, as it would probably still buzz in the frets near the headstock, even with proper neck relief and leveling of the frets in the other end. So what he will do is: neck relief, fret leveling (maybe round them a bit at the fret ends), fix any intonation issues by bending the saddle screws, and possibly install a new nut.

So I owned the guitar for two weeks now, but I have only had it in my possession for about 48 hours, and it's been in the shop since. and tomorrow I will be traveling with the family for one week, so I will not get the guitar back until after that. That's 48 hours with the guitar and then 3 weeks in the shop. That's just too much for me to handle! 😀 I just know that this family vacay is gonna be a case of "Mom, dad is outside, starring into the horizon again, and I think he might be crying".

So, once I do get it back, and get to spend some time with it, I will check back in again with a review of the sounds and feel. And at that time I'm sure the luthier bill will have set me back at least the amount I saved form buying it used, but really I doubt that the previous owner or the shop that fixed the frets sprouts are to blame for the condition my guitar was in when I brought it home. So yeah, maybe the QC is not perfect? Last year I bought a used (but more or less brand new) Squier Classic Vibe Jazzmaster, that was in the exact same condition, except the nut was fine. But it needed a neck shim and fret leveling. When you buy used I'm kinda OK with that, but if you buy brand new, and need to deal with a 3-400 USD luthier bill to make thing playable...
 

TurtlesnTanlines

TDPRI Member
Joined
Oct 21, 2022
Posts
58
Age
36
Location
Houston, TX
Gorgeous guitar. Interestingly, my Tele Ultra has a nut cut issue that’s causing warble…while my MIM replacement neck for my Nashville Tele fits perfectly.
 

fasthand

Tele-Meister
Joined
Dec 29, 2015
Posts
249
Location
Massillon Ohio
My turn I was and still am disappointed in the quality of the fret work
i did purchase at a discount and the shop did improve on unplayable beginnings
I will at some point pay to have it proper leveled crowned and setup at Lays in Kenmore
still thinking about adding a Bigsby so will likely do all at once
over all I like the guitar and am willing to invest in the needed finish work to make it what I believe it can be
besides it smells amazing
C52D0945-9F89-4FF1-9327-55A9E58DBD30.jpeg
 

Feck Studios

Tele-Meister
Joined
Mar 9, 2023
Posts
112
Age
44
Location
Australia
I never buy new guitars, well once, but if they made this without the relic job (not a fan AT ALL) I'D probably seriously concider this.
 

AndrewG

Friend of Leo's
Joined
May 15, 2007
Posts
2,631
Age
70
Location
Exeter, England
Once again we hear confirmation that Fender are evidently cutting corners with the really important things; nuts and frets. During the MIM Standard era I honestly don't recall having to resort to needing extensive fretwork and nut replacement work done-and I went through several Strats and Teles during that period. Or am I imagining things?
The last Player Tele I bought needed a new nut and bad fret sprout fixed, both fortunately done under warranty. My small collection of F-styles now includes no Fenders. My £159 (new) Jet JS-300 S-type, for example, arrived with immaculately dressed frets, rolled edges to the roasted flame maple neck and fretboard, and a perfectly cut bone nut. If some Far East factory can do it, why not a huge multi-national with decades of experience, like Fender? It angers me that we're being asked to shell out getting on for, and exceeding in some cases, £1000 for sub-standard workmanship. It really is a poor show.
 
Last edited:
Top