I'm
IN!!!

This time last year, I posted saying I wasn't eligible for membership...yet. Well, now I am. I pulled the trigger today.
I had an afternoon gig at a seniors community. After it, I went straight to a Mom & Pop (or, more accurately, a Pop, son and grandson) store in town. I knew they were a Fender dealer, so I knew there was a good chance they'd have a Gretsch JD in stock. Sure enough, they did. I played that one first. I also played an Oscar Schmidt by Washburn, and they also were pushing a Luna, so I played that too.
The OS/W was a good looking parlor, but the neck was so slender it wasn't great for fingerstyle. The Luna was a little better, but I wasn't impressed. The Jim Dandy, on the other hand, played
very well. I played "Blackbird" to check out how it played up and down the neck, and fingerstyle. I flat picked "Old Joe Clark" to get a sense of it's response and projection. And of course I strummed away, cowboy chords, barre chords, etc. I even tuned down to Double Dropped D tuning, then to open G. I was duly impressed. And I love the look; as I said before (see post #3 above), it's very close in appearance to the Stella by Harmony that my Dad had in the early '60s. That was a plus for me, as was the pinless bridge.
The shop had a $299 MSRP sticker on the back of the headstock. They then told me they could let it go for $189. Of course, I knew going in that it sold at a street price of $169, so I didn't bite. I looked at those other guitars, and a used Epiphone they had. After a bit, they told me that if I got it today, they'd go $150 and throw in a strap. So I pulled the trigger.
About the strings, according to the Gretsch web page for the JD, it's strung with D'Addario EJ16s (12-53). But that's not what this shop had on the guitar I bought (but these feel like 12s). When it comes time to change them, I'll try the EJ16s. And so the fun begins!