There's a station off I-84 around Middletown, NY that usually has the lowest price according to gasbuddy. Someone is playin' games. They're always a nickel more than the stations you drove past when you get there.
GasBuddy relies on users to report prices. All a station has to do is have the employees report a lower price than what is on the pump and it will drive traffic into the station.
Genius, but pure evil.