Duke of Tone? Or, should I spring for the Prince???

  • Thread starter E5RSY
  • Start date
  • This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links like Ebay, Amazon, and others.

E5RSY

Doctor of Teleocity
Joined
Mar 5, 2009
Posts
13,073
Location
Central Texas
I guess my main question boils down to: Are they the same?

Thanks for any input.

Scott
 

uriah1

Telefied
Ad Free Member
Joined
Feb 12, 2011
Posts
33,493
Location
Around
Didnt know about the duke. Just the King and the Prince.
 

Killing Floor

In Memoriam
Ad Free Member
Joined
Feb 3, 2021
Posts
20,458
Location
Austin, TX
Didnt know about the duke. Just the King and the Prince.
Duke is made by MXR as a sort of collaboration or license agreement. Not sure of the actual arrangement. But Analogman has the hand in design and they even show it on their website. Just saying it’s not a clone.
 

SuperPA

TDPRI Member
Joined
Jan 5, 2020
Posts
50
Age
55
Location
Northeast Ohio
They’re the same price new, so I guess it boils down to form factor and how bad you want it. Getting a prince is a gamble. He releases them at 1pm est on wednesdays, and if you’re late forget it. (Hint: create an account and have payment saved and it’s not too hard). Duke is in stock everywhere so you could have it anytime.
 

blues

Tele-Holic
Joined
Oct 4, 2003
Posts
964
Location
Pa
Had both they can sound the same. The mxr does not have the dip switches that the prince has. If I recall correctly it has the mini pot inside like the prince.

But you can get them to sound the same. I was able to do it because I had both at the same time.

If you're not familiar with the circuit I would just grab the mxr. Plus it's less of a hassle to get a new one.

Also if you're not familiar with the circuit it's not really like a blues breaker. I see a lot of posts saying its a blues breaker clone.

Regardless it's a pretty cool pedal. Btw Analogman designed it and mxr made it work as a mass produced pedal
 
Last edited:

blues

Tele-Holic
Joined
Oct 4, 2003
Posts
964
Location
Pa
They’re the same price new, so I guess it boils down to form factor and how bad you want it. Getting a prince is a gamble. He releases them at 1pm est on wednesdays, and if you’re late forget it. (Hint: create an account and have payment saved and it’s not too hard). Duke is in stock everywhere so you could have it anytime.
He also set a limit on the prince. He will only sell you two and your done.
 

ShaneyWaney

TDPRI Member
Joined
Sep 13, 2023
Posts
14
Age
35
Location
NC
I’ve had all three and I’m currently rocking the Duke. It’s actually very solidly built and the footswitch on it is fantastic. They all sound the same, and what I noticed was the Duke has the internal trim pot set to around 50% from the factory, versus anything straight from Analogman has the presence trim pot at 0%.

The trim pot makes a huge difference to the overall tone, and I’d bet not many reviewers tried to dial it in between each pedal. Also, I like being able to get a replacement pedal that’s readily available as someone who gigs regularly, and that won’t be the case with anything but the MXR without overpaying or waiting. Hope that helps.
 

E5RSY

Doctor of Teleocity
Joined
Mar 5, 2009
Posts
13,073
Location
Central Texas
I’ve had all three and I’m currently rocking the Duke. It’s actually very solidly built and the footswitch on it is fantastic. They all sound the same, and what I noticed was the Duke has the internal trim pot set to around 50% from the factory, versus anything straight from Analogman has the presence trim pot at 0%.

The trim pot makes a huge difference to the overall tone, and I’d bet not many reviewers tried to dial it in between each pedal. Also, I like being able to get a replacement pedal that’s readily available as someone who gigs regularly, and that won’t be the case with anything but the MXR without overpaying or waiting. Hope that helps.
Additionally, as Mike (somewhat surprisingly) mentioned in the MXR launch video, all you have to do is buy two Dukes, use them together, and you got yourself a King of Tone. No wait and a lot cheaper.
 

JesterR

Tele-Afflicted
Joined
Jul 8, 2009
Posts
1,711
Location
Internet
They all sound the same, and what I noticed was the Duke has the internal trim pot set to around 50% from the factory, versus anything straight from Analogman has the presence trim pot at 0%.
And this is more puzzling, since Analogman mentioned, that stock sound IS presence all the way off. And only if you want that extra-presence for your rig, you can turn it up. I like extra spark, so mine is about 30% up now.
 

Andy B

Friend of Leo's
Ad Free Member
Joined
Mar 16, 2003
Posts
3,584
Location
Castle Rock, Colorado
Get the Prince. You have the availability to switch Op Amps. I use TL072 Op Amps in both my POT and KOT. The FET front end of the TL072 is my favorite. LM4580 is Mos Fet whole different sound.
 
Top