Black Oak Arkansas / ST

  • Thread starter dukewellington
  • Start date
  • This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links like Ebay, Amazon, and others.

Sparky2

Poster Extraordinaire
Ad Free Member
Joined
Apr 15, 2017
Posts
7,815
Age
66
Location
Harvest, Alabama
Might want to take your graph right back to my post #14. I never much liked them and absolutely hated the business of smashing guitars because at the time, I was struggling to get my first good guitar.

Bob
Sorry, Bob.

I didn't realize that the observation on smashing guitars meant that you disliked Black Oak.

I'm with you on the smashing guitars thing.
I always hated that nonsense, whether it was BOA, Paul Stanley, or Pete Townsend.
I worked too hard to earn the money to buy a guitar, and smashing any guitar is like a slap to the face of every struggling teenager who aspired to hold that guitar on stage some day.

As for Black Oak, back in the day, they didn't exactly grab me.
Jim Dandy's bold, masculine schtick was a bid off-putting to me, especially considering that he was only around 5' 4" or so tall.

Okay, anyway.
So the graph is now corrected, sir.
😬


boa 2.png
 

Bob Womack

Friend of Leo's
Joined
May 28, 2016
Posts
4,553
Location
Between Clever and Stupid
Sorry, Bob.

I didn't realize that the observation on smashing guitars meant that you disliked Black Oak.

I'm with you on the smashing guitars thing.
I always hated that nonsense, whether it was BOA, Paul Stanley, or Pete Townsend.
I worked too hard to earn the money to buy a guitar, and smashing any guitar is like a slap to the face of every struggling teenager who aspired to hold that guitar on stage some day.

As for Black Oak, back in the day, they didn't exactly grab me.
Jim Dandy's bold, masculine schtick was a bid off-putting to me, especially considering that he was only around 5' 4" or so tall.

Okay, anyway.
So the graph is now corrected, sir.
😬


View attachment 1365199
Hah! Yer killin' me.

Bob
 

Chiogtr4x

Telefied
Ad Free Member
Joined
Mar 29, 2007
Posts
20,375
Location
Manassas Park, VA
Looks ain’t deceiving.
They were way more show than substance.
As a HS kid, I loved the whole 'Southern Rock band' thing ( wanted to play like that...)

So when it came to Black Oak Arkansas, there was an initial attraction, but the way the singer looked and sang ( he could NOT!) was just a deal breaker. Just couldn't get into them- seemed like a parody of a band
 

brookdalebill

Tele Axpert
Ad Free Member
Joined
Nov 15, 2009
Posts
161,717
Age
68
Location
Wimberley, Tx
As a HS kid, I loved the whole 'Southern Rock band' thing ( wanted to play like that...)

So when it came to Black Oak Arkansas, there was an initial attraction, but the way the singer looked and sang ( he could NOT!) was just a deal breaker. Just couldn't get into them- seemed like a parody of a band
My take, too.
It’s slightly ironic that Shawn Lane, arguably one of the most impressive shedders that ever lived was a (latter day) member.
In BOA’s defense, they did “make show” (Mach Shau - as the owner of the Kaiserkeller told the Beatles).
I just dug the Ruby Starr era, probably for all the wrong reasons. :rolleyes: :rolleyes:
 

Papanate

Tele-Afflicted
Joined
Nov 11, 2018
Posts
1,558
Age
55
Location
New York
So I took a long break from this album (why did I do that?) and put it on the spindle again tonight for the first time in years.

God, I missed it. Listening to Black Oak again feels like I just got home. You can hear that they love what they’re doing. And that fuzz-reverb-sustain triple threat. That’s the special sauce. Yes!
I remember seeing them in the Early 70s - whenever Ruby Starr joined them - I also remember her Grey Ghost album - both bands seemed like an act more than a band - although Tommy Aldridge was amazing - and it was because of Aldridge that I went to see them - this was before he joined Pat Travers - who I also saw - it was eye opening to watch - he made the drums come alive.

BOA was more of a Vaudeville act to me and my friends - the Band played well - but Dandy and Starr just seem to be Fluff.
 

pippoman

Friend of Leo's
Joined
Feb 21, 2014
Posts
2,206
Location
Memphis
'When Electricity Came to Arkansas' was always one of my favorites!!!


I saw them live - once. Jim Dandy was a great showman and the musicians were very good, but I didn’t really care for them all that much like my friends did who bragged so much about them. Jim Dandy was vulgar to say the least. Barnstorm opened for them, so definitely not a total loss.
 

dukewellington

Tele-Holic
Joined
Mar 8, 2021
Posts
645
Location
Prairie plains
I saw them live - once. Jim Dandy was a great showman and the musicians were very good, but I didn’t really care for them all that much like my friends did who bragged so much about them. Jim Dandy was vulgar to say the least. Barnstorm opened for them, so definitely not a total loss.
Absolutely vulgar! To the rescue… otoh I’ve heard good firsthand stories about him, personally.

Would have loved to hang with those guys in the early days. They knew their stuff from early blues and jazz to hillbilly. Maybe that’s why I like them. They seem to remind me of friends.
 

clydethecat

Telefied
Ad Free Member
Joined
Mar 17, 2003
Posts
22,450
Age
69
Location
The Far-Flung Isles of Langerhans
What I read later, is that although they played Gibson 335s on stage, they switched them out for cheap knockoffs for the guitar smashing. Smart.

Usually Ventura 335 knockoffs, I think.

I mixed a Black Oak Arkansas show in a small club some years ago, in the late '90s I think. It was booked as a "Jim's Birthday" show, but had been re-scheduled a couple of times. It was Jim and Ricky Lee Reynolds, and some younger guys. It was a very easy show, Jim and Ricky were both really nice people to work with. Jim had no business wearing spandex, but that didn't stop him.

Being in Arkansas, obviously the first album in 1971 was huge here.
 
Last edited:

4Teles

Tele-Meister
Joined
Nov 5, 2006
Posts
209
Location
hampton beach nh
I saw them several times unfortunately. They seemed to be the resident opening act for all my favorite bands in the early 70’s. Three guitar players who’s combined talent brought them to a singular level of mediocrity. And then there was the leering Jim Dandy whose spandex clothed pecker on full display being repeatedly thrust at the audience while he jerked off a washboard out of time. All that between croaking out hillbilly bs vocals…BOA was a joke and an insult all at once. Horrible.
 
Top