Is your Vibro Champ an old warrior? Frankly, given that it's home use only, I would not buy either. Perhaps, a good reverb/tremolo pedal and you'd be set: all-tube champ with classic effects, and MIII for headphones, recording, and possibly gig out. Do think twice before you go bigger because you seem to have the perfect setup! Or, if I wanted to spend that kind of money on an amp at all cost, I'd get a small tweed. Just my .02!