Separate names with a comma.
Discussion in 'Guitar Owners Clubs' started by Kayle McGuire, Dec 15, 2017.
Would anybody reach for a Squier before a Fender? Or choose an Epiphone over a Gibson?
I choose Epi over Gibson because I can actually afford 'em. I've found Epiphone quality to be very consistent, and, frankly, the price of entry means o don't have to baby them.
Only because of cost.
I have an Epi LP Deluxe with mini-hums that is amazing. Can't afford the Gibson, paid $1500 less for my Epi. So yes, I reach for that.
I also have a first year Squier CV Thinline that I grab because it's a great guitar. Yeah, I can tell the difference, wood-feel, solidity, sure, but through an amp--no one else can. So yes, I grab that one too.
Well no not really. I like some of the imported guitars especially the classic vibes. But there is a much wider variety of choice in the main lines of Fender and Gibson that its easier to find a instrument that suits my style.
All of my guitars (save a 45 year-old Framus and a Pignose travel guitar) are either Gibson or Fender. So I guess, no.
If you're talking about choosing one particular guitar over another, all bets are off; there are dogs and jewels from any company, and I do believe that primo squiers/epis could overcome poor fenders/gibbys.
If you're talking about two guitars hiding behind curtains and all we get to know about them is the name on the headstock, yeah, I'm going gibby/fender.
When I went looking for a rosewood board Tele, my local Fender dealer had two, a Squier Classic Vibe Custom, and an American Special. The American Special stayed in the store and the Squier came home with me. Yes, the American one was better quality, but the Squier played just as well, sounded better to me ('cause the pickups sounded more vintage than the Texas Specials in the American one), and cost half as much.
But, it all depends on which Squier vs. which Fender, and which Epi vs. which Gibby.
Cost would be the only thing making the answer to your question "yes" for a lot of people. If cost were no object, of course we'd pick Gibson and Fender over the other two.
I’ve played quite a number of Epiphones that I quite liked, I’ve played 3 Gibsons that I liked enough to notice. I’ve never played a squier that I liked more than the novelty of “that’s better than I expected” and have very rarely played a fender that I didn’t think was great, or at least very likable.
In short: I would almost always grab an Epiphone over a Gibson, and almost never grab a squier over a fender.
I don't own a fender or a gibson...or an epi for that matter.
+1 I feel exactly the same way. It is not a clear line at times though, because both Squier and Epi have quite a price range/quality line in their own right, so that needs to be kept in mind here. I think Epi stands out from Squier in many ways, but most importantly there is not a good middle ground for Gibson, whereas, Fender has the MIM line that are for the most part outstanding. So, it is pretty easy to bypass the Squier line and go Fender MIM, but jumping from Epi to Gibson is a huge jump that is difficult to justify in ways more than just financial.
Same here. Depending on the model the best Epis are 80%-90% the same as their Gibson counterpart for a fraction of the cost. No reason not to play them unless someone needs the headstock to say Gibson.
The Squier CV Series is very much up to par with it's Fender counterparts as well and also quite easy to upgrade to an MIA level for far less money than a new MIA would run. I own two Tele and two Basses I've done just that with and few would even know they were Squiers when they stared out except for the logo.
It's not like we're talking the difference between 24k gold and junk gold here.
The tribute line of Gibsons, I would say, are somewhat akin to the MIM fenders in relation to the USA counterparts. (Ironically, 2 of the 3 gibsons I remember actually enjoying were tributes. The 60’s tribute with P90s and the futura tribute P90/HB. The other was a custom shop es330 with natural finish)
It depends....I'm loaded up with Squiers (VM Jazzmaster, VM Jaguar, VM 72 Thinline, CV 60's Strat, HSS affinity Strat) because their price point allows me to experiment and try different models. At the moment, I have no Fender gear., but I might upgrade to Americans (Jazzmaster and Jag) at some point because the build quality is significantly better, but don't feel compelled to any time soon. In general I feel that Squier has done a particularly good job with their VM and CV series, though their sudden price hike a few years back took a little bit of the shine off. Still great bang for the buck.
I have a few Epiphones (LP Special I- yellow P90, Wildkat, EJ200SCE, and the Electar Amp) that I am happy with. The Wildkat in particular is a great guitar and fun to play, and Gibson has no equivalent. I had an Epi LP plus-top a while back, which I think was a good guitar, but didn't seem as nice as some of my friends' Gibson LPs in terms of general feel and playability (although to be fair they invested a great deal of time and money getting their LPs "just right"). I just picked up a used Michael Kelly Patriot Custom Quilted LP that I think is more comparable to the Gibsons I had played, but it had also been professionally set up.
With Gibson brands, the difference and price between the Epi and Gibson definitely has me leaning toward the cheaper, but still pretty dang good Epiphones. I was able to pick up a Gibson 2015 SG Standard on the cheap, and love the feel and sound of it, but would never have paid full retail for it over an Epi SG 400 pro, which is also a pretty nice guitar for a fraction of the price. The 57 classic pickups on the Gibson SG were just too good to pass up.
Here are two reasons, not mine but I do have one like the first one:
Price. If you've only got $200 you might as well forget Gibson and Fender. Squier and Epiphone both make great starter guitars for noobs or fixer uppers for the crafty.
I have an Epiphone SG G400 that gets way more play time than the Gibson SG.
I have non-Fender entry-level Strats that get played more than Squier but about the same as Fender. Reason is most of the budget Squiers go way too thin on the neck carves while the non-Fenders actually get the necks right. Maybe Squier should offer both the thin and the fat necks in those starter guitars (the upper VM/etc do but at those prices I hop over to MIM).
Not included in the survey question but I play PRS SEs more often than the vintage PRS I have.
I’d be more inclined toward an Epi than a Squier, though. If I liked Gibbo designs and scale lengths, I’d be all over an Epi. But a used Fender (MIM) is very little more than an upper-end Squier, so I’d go with the Fender.
I have an Epiphone Elitist Sheraton. I wouldn't say its necessarily better than the Gibson 335 I used to own, but it is quite a nice instrument, and good luck finding a Gibson semi with mini humbuckers.