This isn't about which speaker brand is the best. I know everyone loves Weber, Celestion and Eminence etc. I did a 5e3 build recently and I happened to have a newer P12Q on hand, so that's what I put in there. After playing it for a few weeks, it kinda seems that the P12Q might be too much speaker for the 5e3. The bottom is nice but seems to be a tad too much and it seems to have too much volume. I'm not getting the breakup that I was expecting. Before laying down over a hundred more I thought I'd check with you guys to get your opinions. How much difference is there between the R & Q volume wise, bass response wise and breakup wise? I know the originals came with the R.