Actually I just tested these two out together last week. I wound up going with the tone wicker version. Supposedly with the tone switch on and the wicker switch off it's supposed to be the exact same circuit as the regular one, and it was close enough, but I could hear a slight difference between the two. I like the versatility of the TW, simply because it can pull of the original sound and do a bit more.
This is what I think. If you like it, keep it. If you don't, send it right back.