Trouble with two volume tele

I recently build a tele and decided to wire it up with two volume knobs and a switch, since i always have the tone knob all the way up on my other tele.

I'm not going to change anything, as i find it VERY handy.. When i have the switch for the bridge position, even when i turn the volume all the way down, the signal still comes through. But it's kinda like if you have the volume down 3/4 of the way. It's a very clean signal. Then all the way up is louder and really drives the amp. So to completely shut the signal off, i just leave the neck pickup volume down and use the switch like a killswitch.

I have no idea how this could happen, any ideas?

wire it thisaway ...

http://www.seymourduncan.com/support/wiring-diagrams/schematics.php?schematic=tele_2v_no_tone