No offense to the LP users -- I know it's a different beast. As an aside, about 20 years ago I owned an original Hagstrom Swede. It sounded exactly like the LP guitars on Super Session (Bloomfield, Kooper, Stills). But even with its killer tone, the body shape didn't work for me and it was way too heavy. I've got a broken collar bone on my strap side, so lighter guitars are generally a better option for me.
Back to the main question: the majority consensus reveals an even split between #2 and #3. The unknown for me is the 11" radius on the Tele Deluxe. And I wonder about the different scale length on the Jaguar. Does anyone have any direct experience making these transitions from a 9.5 radius and standard Fender scale length?