Originally Posted by Bartholomew3
That's what I was going to say also...seem to be moving the saddle in the wrong direction according to the OP.
Ditto. I tune the harmonic and adjust to the fretted. If the fretted is sharp, I move the saddle back. So if you are doing the inverse (tune to the fretted, and adjust the harmonic), you'd need to move the saddle forward.