I'm chiming in late on this thread but I use either my '52ri or a LP copy depending on the other electric player's choice that day. He uses an ash tele or an Epiphone LP custom thru a Vox. The pastor plays in the other band (we alternate bands) and uses a MIA Strat via Line 6. The 2nd guitarist in THAT group uses an SG and Line 6.
I've only gotten comments about my amp. I use a Budda SD18 and wound up covering up the logo plate while filling in at a friend's youth group when he took over.
The pastor at my home church is always telling me to turn it up louder, so I got that going for me