Quote:
|
The judges seem to be there just to try to create some drama in the show. You have 3 people who are flambouyant with possible scripted responses from the writers...
|
Scripted? Even bad writers would try to put some variety into the judges comments. If Simon's comments were scripted, I doubt we'd hear the cruise ship-Holiday Inn analogy so often. And Paula's comments can be boiled down to phrase I utter to my wife whenever she is about to render her verdict -- "You're a bright shining light."
Apparently, the judges watch the dress rehearsal to help them prepare their comments ahead of time. I think that's as far as it goes.